EVIDENCE-BASED SUPPLEMENT SCORING
8.1/10
SOLID OPTION

Confidence: 80%

Carlyle Grass Fed Whey Protein Powder | 5lb (80 oz) | 33g of Protein Per Serving | Unflavored | Sugar and Hormone Free | Non-GMO and Gluten Free Supplement | by Herbage Farmstead

Carlyle Grass Fed Whey Protein Powder | 5lb (80 oz) | 33g of Protein Per Serving | Unflavored | Sugar and Hormone Free | Non-GMO and Gluten Free Supplement | by Herbage Farmstead

B0BSR8HM93

View on Amazon →

SuppScoreLab compares supplement products for informational purposes. We do not sell products directly, and some links may take you to third-party retailers.

Decision summary

CONSIDERSOLID OPTION

A solid product, but not a clean win. The main trade-off is weaker ingredient form quality.

Best for

People prioritizing high absorption and overall formula quality.

Consider another option if

You care a lot about label clarity and want fewer unknowns.

Score breakdown

Tap a module to see what it measures. A 0 can reflect missing disclosure, not just a negative result.

Dosage quality

9.4/10

Strong dosing for the intended goal

Checks whether labeled ingredient amounts fall within clinically studied ranges (not just regulatory minimums). Low/0 can reflect under-dosing or missing amounts (e.g., proprietary blends).

Score summary

Whey-protein: dose within clinically studied range (evidence A). The main limitation is that serving size or servings_per_container missing (-2).

Strengths

Whey-protein: dose within clinically studied range (evidence A)

Weaknesses

Serving size or servings_per_container missing (-2)
Product name or brand not detected (-1)

Final verdict

A solid product, but not a clean win. The main trade-off is weaker ingredient form quality.

Ingredient Analysis & Evidence

A closer look at the main ingredients, how they influence the score, and the supporting evidence when available. Tap any ingredient to expand.

✔ Clinically effective dose with strong supporting evidence

Dose is within the optimal/effective range.

Scientific evidence

Meta-analysis

Tang et al. meta-analysis protein supplementation and muscle mass gain

British Journal of Nutrition • 2009

PMID: 22150425.0

Carlyle Grass Fed Whey Protein Powder | 5lb (80 oz) | 33g of Protein Per Serving | Unflavored | Sugar and Hormone Free | Non-GMO and Gluten Free Supplement | by Herbage Farmstead

Carlyle Grass Fed Whey Protein Powder | 5lb (80 oz) | 33g of Protein Per Serving | Unflavored | Sugar and Hormone Free | Non-GMO and Gluten Free Supplement | by Herbage Farmstead

Warnings & notes

Important label or formulation details that may affect how this product should be interpreted.

i

Some label details are missing or unclear

Incomplete disclosure makes the product harder to evaluate confidently.

Info

There is a formulation caveat worth noting

Product name or brand not detected (-1)

Note

Methodology

Read our methodology overview to understand how SuppScoreLab combines multiple scientific dimensions into one practical score.

View methodology →

This evaluation is based on the product label and declared Supplement Facts available at review time. It does not verify laboratory-tested composition, purity, or batch-level quality. This content is educational and not medical advice. Consult a qualified healthcare professional for personal health decisions. Affiliate disclosure: SuppScoreLab may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon links.

Still comparing options?

See the best Protein Powder supplements ranked with the same methodology, or keep exploring the database.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.