EVIDENCE-BASED SUPPLEMENT SCORING
7.7/10
SOLID OPTION

Confidence: 95%

CANLIST Extra Strength Melatonin 10mg Tablets, Sleep Support, Fall Asleep Faster, Non-Habit Forming Sleep Aids for Adults, Sleep Cycle Regulation, Vegan, Non-GMO & Gluten-Free, 120 Tablets

CANLIST Extra Strength Melatonin 10mg Tablets, Sleep Support, Fall Asleep Faster, Non-Habit Forming Sleep Aids for Adults, Sleep Cycle Regulation, Vegan, Non-GMO & Gluten-Free

B0F8BDCYVP

View on Amazon →

SuppScoreLab compares supplement products for informational purposes. We do not sell products directly, and some links may take you to third-party retailers.

Decision summary

CONSIDERSOLID OPTION

A solid product, but not a clean win. The main trade-off is weaker dosing.

Best for

People prioritizing high absorption and overall formula quality.

Consider another option if

You want fewer compromises on formulation quality.

Score breakdown

Tap a module to see what it measures. A 0 can reflect missing disclosure, not just a negative result.

Dosage quality

5.8/10

Acceptable dosing, but not standout

Checks whether labeled ingredient amounts fall within clinically studied ranges (not just regulatory minimums). Low/0 can reflect under-dosing or missing amounts (e.g., proprietary blends).

Multi-ingredient formulation analysis

Dose 5.8/10 · Bioavailability 6.7/10 · Coherence 6/10

This is a multi-ingredient product. The score reflects formulation quality, not efficacy for a specific health goal.

Score summary

Melatonin: high-bioavailability form declared (Melatonin). The main limitation is that formula coherence is weak: diluted, decorative or overly complex.

Strengths

Melatonin: high-bioavailability form declared (Melatonin)
Theanine: high-bioavailability form declared (L Theanine)

Weaknesses

Formula coherence is weak: diluted, decorative or overly complex
Lemon-balm: below clinically studied range

Final verdict

A solid product, but not a clean win. The main trade-off is weaker dosing.

Ingredient Analysis & Evidence

A closer look at the main ingredients, how they influence the score, and the supporting evidence when available. Tap any ingredient to expand.

✔ Clinically effective dose with strong supporting evidence

Dose is within the optimal/effective range. Adequate, but not a key strength: Dose is directionally useful, but not a standout strength. The declared form supports strong absorption.

Scientific evidence

Meta-analysis

Ferracioli-Oda et al. meta-analysis melatonin and sleep disorders

PLOS ONE • 2013

PMID: 23691095.0

ℹ At the minimum effective range, but below the optimal dose with moderate supporting evidence

Dose meets the minimum effective range, but is below the optimal dose used for stronger effects. This is a limiting factor: Dose is below the ranges usually used for stronger effects. The declared form supports strong absorption.

Scientific evidence

RCT

Owen et al. RCT theanine and caffeine on cognitive performance

Nutritional Neuroscience • 2008

PMID: 18681988.0

RCT

Lu et al. RCT L-theanine and stress response in healthy adults

Nutritional Neuroscience • 2004

PMID: 16930802.0

✔ Clinically effective dose with moderate supporting evidence

Dose is within the optimal/effective range. One of the weaker points: Dose is below the ranges usually used for stronger effects.

Scientific evidence

RCT

Bryan et al. RCT on B vitamins and cognitive function in older adults

American Journal of Clinical Nutrition • 2002

PMID: 16920179.0

⚠ Moderate evidence exists, but dose is below effective threshold

Dose is below the minimum effective threshold. One of the weaker points: Dose is likely below clinically useful levels.

Scientific evidence

RCT

Ngan et al. RCT lemon balm and mood and sleep

Nutrients • 2014

PMID: 22995013.0

✔ Dose aligned with moderate supporting evidence

Adequate, but not a key strength: Clinical dosing guidance is limited for this ingredient.

Scientific evidence

RCT

Hieu et al. systematic review chamomile and sleep quality

Phytomedicine • 2019

PMID: 28214677.0

Evidence inferred from established knowledge, not directly linked studies

Adequate, but not a key strength: Clinical dosing guidance is limited for this ingredient.

No supporting studies or dosing references are currently available for this ingredient.

CANLIST Extra Strength Melatonin 10mg Tablets, Sleep Support, Fall Asleep Faster, Non-Habit Forming Sleep Aids for Adults, Sleep Cycle Regulation, Vegan, Non-GMO & Gluten-Free, 120 Tablets

CANLIST Extra Strength Melatonin 10mg Tablets, Sleep Support, Fall Asleep Faster, Non-Habit Forming Sleep Aids for Adults, Sleep Cycle Regulation, Vegan, Non-GMO & Gluten-Free, 120 Tablets

Warnings & notes

Important label or formulation details that may affect how this product should be interpreted.

Formula design looks less coherent than stronger alternatives

The formulation appears less focused than better-built options.

Note
!

Lemon Balm dose looks below clinically effective levels

Declared amount falls below ranges used in human trials.

Warning

Methodology

Read our methodology overview to understand how SuppScoreLab combines multiple scientific dimensions into one practical score.

View methodology →

This evaluation is based on the product label and declared Supplement Facts available at review time. It does not verify laboratory-tested composition, purity, or batch-level quality. This content is educational and not medical advice. Consult a qualified healthcare professional for personal health decisions. Affiliate disclosure: SuppScoreLab may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon links.

Still comparing options?

See the best Melatonin supplements ranked with the same methodology, or keep exploring the database.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.